In 1952, Cagles Mill Lake was built as Indiana’s first flood control reservoir, protecting the Eel and White river watersheds. Mill Creek feeds the 1,400-acre lake and is home to beautiful Cataract Falls. These falls resulted from two pre-glacial bedrock ridges buried beneath ancient lake sediments of the Illinoisan glacial period.  Waterskiing and other water contact sports are permitted out here. 

The best baits for this lake

Strike King Bladed jigs 1/2 oz / Blue Glimmer Thunder Cricket

Bladed Jigs

Shop
LUNKERCANDY Crankbaits Cell Mate Sugar Daddy 6

Crankbaits

Shop

Fishing Jigs

Shop
Strike King Finesse baits Dirt Perfect Plastic Finesse Worm

Finesse Baits

Shop

Jerkbaits

Shop
LUNKERCANDY Crankbaits Sunrise Salabasaurus Rex

Panfish Baits

Shop